Benny's Pizza

Discover Benny's Pizza in Milan, IL, offering delicious QC-style pizza, buffalo chicken, taco, bacon cheeseburger pizza, cheesy sticks, calzone, and fresh salads. Call +1 309-756-0013 today!

Welcome to Benny's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza welcomes everyone with open arms and a slice of joy. Located at 687 Hillcrest Rd, Milan, IL, this pizza gem delivers a true taste of QC style pizza that locals adore. The charming atmosphere draws in families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts, making every visit a reason to celebrate. Benny's offers an array of favorite pies, from the unique buffalo chicken and taco pizzas to the classic cheese sticks and calzones. With great pizza and a fun vibe, this is a spot where memories are made and appetites are satisfied.

Whether it's a busy Saturday or a quiet weekday evening, Benny's promises smiles along with a delicious meal. With a phone number of +1 309-756-0013, it's easy to call ahead or place an order for pickup.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

687 Hillcrest Rd, Milan, IL 61264, United States

Phone

+1 309-756-0013

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza isn't just a restaurant; it's a cornerstone of the Milan community. Established as the go-to locale for pizza lovers, this eatery merges quality ingredients with generous portions. The authentic QC style pizza garners rave reviews from families, couples, and solo diners alike. The reduced prices and family-sized options act as a perfect solution for gatherings; large pizza and an array of appetizers make meal planning a breeze.

The standout items like the buffalo chicken pizza and taco pizza spark conversations and cravings that lured many into its doors. Community members often mention the friendly staff who turn each visit into an enjoyable experience. The aesthetic of Benny's combines rustic charm with casual seating, allowing for intimate gatherings or fun-filled family dining. Serving size and quality coalesce here; a large pizza coupled with cheesy breadsticks becomes an unforgettable feast.

On busy nights and weekends, the restaurant thrives.

Saturdays see the pinnacle of patronage, with a bustling 100% capacity at 5 PM. The heart of Milan pulses here, with laughter and the aroma of freshly baked pizzas filling the air. Interestingly, peace returns shortly after the dinner rush, allowing for more relaxed dining experiences. Visitors can avoid the crowds by choosing times earlier in the day, especially during lunch hours, or late evenings that reveal a tranquil yet equally delightful dining alternative.

Benny's Pizza mirrors the spirit of its patrons—lively, warm, and always ready to serve a delicious slice. Each pizza serves as a canvas for creativity; patrons often customize their orders, enhancing the shared experience of enjoying a meal that's uniquely theirs.

In a town that loves its pizza, Benny's continues to radiate charm, flavor, and community spirit—making it a must-visit destination in Milan.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • Monday4-8 PM
  • Tuesday4-8 PM
  • Wednesday4-8 PM
  • Thursday4-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Benny's Pizza stands out with its extensive menu features and vibrant community atmosphere. Enjoy specialties like the Chicken & Spinach pizza or the mouthwatering Banker's Special while relaxing in a family-friendly setting. The restaurant prides itself on its peak times, welcoming crowds during Saturday dinner at 5 PM, catering to all pizza cravings effortlessly. Guests can indulge in not only an impressive range of pizzas but also calzones, appetizers like crispy Benny's bread, and refreshing drinks.

With an average price of $13.19 for a satisfying meal, Benny's promises good value without compromising quality or taste. Whether you're dining in, picking up, or getting delivery, Benny's Pizza makes every meal delectable and convenient.

Benny's Pizza

The exterior of Benny's Pizza captures the eye with its inviting facade. Bright signage beckons customers, showcasing the irresistible pizza offerings inside. Set against the backdrop of Hillcrest Rd, the outdoor seating invites diners to enjoy their favorite slices in fresh air when the weather permits. The vibe within is vibrant yet cozy, with a mix of contemporary decor and a touch of rustic charm.

Smiling faces fill the dining area, enhancing the welcoming atmosphere that's perfect for family get-togethers or casual outings with friends. It's a place where people feel comfortable as they settle in for a delicious meal. The energy is palpable, particularly on weekends when locals gather to share food and create lasting memories.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

This is easily the best Quad City style pizza out there. The crust is more tender and less chewy and the sauce is bright. We love it!

J
Jen

One of the best places I've been for pizza. I don't live in the area but when I'm in the quad cities I'll pick up a pizza from here (and some cheese sticks) It's usually the banker's special. The sausage they use tastes different than other pizza places but it's delicious! The pizza reheats perfectly in the oven in case you don't finish it. Definitely stop by for some pizza!

S
Sharyl K.

Nice, cozy little place. My family and I have been enjoying dining in. It is quickly becoming a go to spot :-)

G
Geoff S.

This was my first time trying Benny's. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a small cheese stick to go. The employees were friendly and they got done making my food right when their estimated time was. The total was around $35 after taxes, so it's a little bit pricey, but I was very happy with the taste and quality of the food. This was one of the best pizzas I've had in the QCA. I will definitely be back to try some specialty pizzas. Also, I HIGHLY recommend the cheese sticks. Myself, my husband, and our very picky young toddler devoured that!

L
Lindsey H.

Amazing QC pizza and a great local business!

D
Damon L.

My 1st time ordering from this place on door dash...omg! DELICIOUS! we ordered bread app, calzone and pizza...all so good!

a
ann b.